Profile

resqgeek: (Default)
ResQgeek

May 2024

S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
1213141516 1718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Custom Text

Most Popular Tags

Fifteen Years

Sep. 11th, 2016 04:06 pm
resqgeek: (Ambulance)

Today is the fifteenth anniversary of one of the worst days the United States has ever experienced.  If you take even the most casual look around the internet, there is no shortage of posts recalling the events of that horrible day.  Everyone has a story of what they were doing that day, what they felt, how they reacted.  Remembering the events of that day, remembering those who died, sharing our stories, these are all important.


But on this anniversary, I’m not finding myself thinking about that day so much as the years since.  I’m thinking about the legacy of that awful day, how we, as a nation, responded, and what we’ve done since.  I remember how, in the days and weeks immediately afterwards, we came together, expressing incredible solidarity with the victims and communities impacted.  In the midst of the horror and disbelief, it was possible to find hope in the way we reached out to each other in our grief.


But that spirit of hope and unity isn’t very evident today. We have become deeply divided along many fronts.  We have given into fear, sacrificing many of the most important principles. From holding prisoners for years (even decades) without due process, to torturing prisoners, to massive electronic surveillance that has steadily eroded our privacy, we have allowed our fear to justify a steady, incremental surrender of many of the ideal we used to take pride in.  And on top of that, that same fear has led to a rising distrust of immigrants, especially those coming from certain parts of the world, or who profess certain religious beliefs.  We seem to have forgotten that this country is a nation of immigrants, that our immigrant heritage is our great strength, that our future almost certainly rests in those who continue to yearn to come here and become part of our society.


Meanwhile, we obsess over superficial shows of patriotism.  We complain when someone exercises their rights to protest by not following conventional patriotic acts, like standing for the national anthem. We are outraged when someone dares to suggest that we might have overreacted to the terrorist attacks.  We have elevated outrage to the new patriotism.


So, let’s remember the terrible events of that day. It is important to remember and to share those memories.  But it is also important to reflect on how we have responded to that day, and to consider whether, going forward, we can’t find responses that don’t compromise our ideals.  I believe that we can, and that such responses would ultimately be more productive in improving security and promoting peace both at home and abroad.
It is nearly impossible to avoid images from fourteen years ago today, and so I find myself pondering the events of that terrible day and the impact it has had over the intervening years.  The initial response to the attacks was overwhelmingly positive, with people showing tremendous courage and compassion as they worked together, initially to try and save lives, and then to bring comfort and closure to the families of those who could not be rescued.  The incredible unity of spirit that arose, both across the country, and around the world, struck me as a hopeful sign that our common humanity could overcome our differences and unite us all.  In the midst of the tragedy and sorrow, there was a glimmer of hope.

Unfortunately, that spark did not kindle a lasting light of peace.  Instead, we have allowed our anger and fear to conquer our compassion and hope.  We have used the attacks to justify incredible infringements on our liberties, and our misguided efforts to protect our security have made the world a more dangerous place.  We have squandered the good will of people around the world by our incredible arrogance and our selfish efforts to reshape the world to serve our interests.  And for what?  There is little to suggest that we are any safer than we were before the attacks, and the world is, if anything, less stable and more dangerous than it was before.  We have sacrificed our liberties and economy in pursuit of security, with very little to show for it.

And at home, the fear and anger generated by those attacks have festered, growing and transforming like a cancer inside our politics, driving us apart.  It has made it impossible to have a meaningful and productive debate, and our politics have degraded into name-calling and blind rhetoric shouted across the chasm that separates us.  Instead of trying to understand the point of view of the other side, we now dismiss them and their views as stupid (at best) or evil (at worse).  And there doesn't seem to be any indication that any of this will be changing anytime soon.

Today, I think about those who died on that sunny day fourteen years ago.  I wish I could say that we have honored their memories by our collective actions.  But, in truth, I don't think we have.  We have wrapped ourselves in their memory, using them to justify our fear and anger.  This is a grave injustice to those whose lives were cut short.  I can't help but think that it would be a far better memorial to them if we were looking to bring peace to the world, reaching out to help people in need, regardless of their nationality, religion, or politics.  We should be honoring them by looking for solutions to make the world a better place to live, both for ourselves, our children, and our grandchildren, a world that is environmentally sustainable, where we all recognize our common humanity and respect each other.  Instead of focusing on the anger and fear, we need to remember that feeling of unity.  That is the fitting memorial for the victims.
Can it really have been eleven years already? It is hard to fathom how much life has changed since that beautiful late summer day turned into a living nightmare. Clearly, the terrorist attacks of that day changed the course of history, not just for the United States, but for the entire world. But it becomes easier for me to grasp how much time has passed when I look at my own life.

On that day, my younger daughter was just over 6 months old, and as I watched the news coverage, I worried about what the future might hold for her and her sister. Little did we know that she would not live to see the ninth anniversary of the attacks.

On that day, I was less than three years removed from my active involvement with the emergency services community, so the loss of so many brave responders when the World Trade Center towers collapsed hit me with an almost physical force. These were men and women that I considered to be brothers and sisters, linked by our commitment to helping others in their time of need.

On that day, my experiences and horizons were largely limited to one perspective, somewhat provincial in scope, formed by a life lived almost exclusively inside the borders of my home country. In the years since the attack, I have come to value a broader perspective. I’ve found and embraced friends from around the world. I have crossed oceans to visit places that I had only read about. It has broadened my understanding of my place in the world.

On that day, I struggled to understand why someone would lash out in such anger and hatred, willingly giving their lives to attack anonymous strangers on a massive scale. I continue to struggle with these questions, but I’ve come to understand that the answers are not simple, and that, far from helping, many of our responses have made things worse. I find myself disappointed by the some of the ways we have chosen to respond to the attacks. Those things that I was most proud of in the immediate aftermath, such as the outpouring of compassion in the following weeks, have proven fleeting.

There will be memorial services today, and the media will reflect on the events of eleven years ago, and there is nothing wrong with any of that. But I wonder if it is enough. Shouldn’t this anniversary spur us to reflection on how we’ve responded? Wouldn’t a meaningful attempt to build bridges to peace be a more fitting tribute to the memories of those who died that day? I feel like there has been a deep unwillingness to engage in much critical self-reflection as we struggled to respond. We should never forget those who were killed that day, but they deserve more than that. Our actions should reflect honor upon their memories, leaving the world a better place for everyone.
Tags:

Ten years.

Sep. 1st, 2011 10:42 pm
resqgeek: (Default)
Having just observed the first anniversary of the tragic death of our daughter, I suddenly find myself confronted by the impending tenth anniversary of the incredible tragedy of 11 September 2001. My younger daughter was not quite 7 months old on that fateful day, and as I watch the specials about the preparations of the memorial in New York on the Discovery Channel, I find myself with a clearer appreciation for the families of those that died on that day. Our grief, as powerful as it is to us, is dwarfed by the magnitude of sadness of ten years ago.

I remember how powerfully I felt the impact of the images I saw on television that day. I was only three years removed from my own volunteer career in Emergency Services, so that the deaths of the fire fighters and paramedics that day were especially personal to me. It hardly seemed possible to me at the time, and I could easily put myself in the boots of those that ran into those towers that day, hoping to make a difference in the lives of those in harm's way. I spent that afternoon sitting in front of the television, watching the video of the collapsing towers, over and over again.

Now, almost ten years later, I look back, and I still feel a bit of that pain and shock. I still find it hard to believe that those buildings failed so catastrophically. I still feel anger towards those that planned and executed these attacks. But at the same time, I'm embarrassed by many of the things my nation has done in response.

All of this has faded with the passage of time, and last year's personal tragedy has overpowered those lingering emotions from a decade earlier. But our sorrow was the result of a tragic accident. The deaths of 11 September 2001 were the result of a callously premeditated attack. We've managed to find healing by focusing on the positive memories of our daughter and in the tremendous support we've found in our family, friends and community. I can only pray that the families that died that awful day in New York, Pennsylvania and Arlington, VA can find similar memories to comfort and heal them. Certainly they can be sure that their loved ones will never be forgotten.
Tags:
Tags:

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

Style Credit